1937 AFA Awards |
| All-AFA | Position | Team | Selectors |
|---|---|---|---|
| Red Mays | E | Paterson Panthers | OFF |
| Leo Paquin | E | Newark Tornadoes | OFF |
| Al Kanya | T | Paterson Panthers | OFF |
| Ed Marinowski | T | Newark Tornadoes | OFF |
| Ted Beck | G | White Plains Bears | OFF |
| Jerry Shaw | G | Brooklyn Eagles | OFF |
| Ray Otlowski | C | Newark Tornadoes | OFF |
| Floyd Sexton | QB | Brooklyn Eagles | OFF |
| Rudy Choborda | HB | Newark Tornadoes | OFF |
| Joe Mandell | HB | White Plains Bears | OFF |
| Ed Smith | FB | Newark Tornadoes | OFF |
| OFF=Official |