| Day | Date | | Opponent | Score | | | Location | Venue | Attendance | Notes |
|---|
| Sun | 9/28/1924 | H | Ambridge Eagles | 20-0 | W | | Toronto, OH | Kilgus Field | | |
| Sun | 10/5/1924 | H | Valley All-Stars | 26-0 | W | | Toronto, OH | Kilgus Field | | |
| Sun | 10/12/1924 | H | Altoona Victoria Indians | 38-0 | W | | Toronto, OH | Kilgus Field | | |
| Sun | 10/19/1924 | H | Akron Pros | 14-24 | L | | Toronto, OH | Kilgus Field | 3500 | |
| Sun | 10/26/1924 | A | Martins Ferry Queensboro A.C. | 18-0 | W | | Martins Ferry, OH | | | |
| Sun | 11/2/1924 | H | McKeesport Olympics | 6-0 | W | | Toronto, OH | Kilgus Field | | |
| Sun | 11/16/1924 | A | Steubenville Ex-Collegians | 0-10 | L | | Steubenville, OH | North End Field | 5000 | |
| Sun | 11/23/1924 | H | Steubenville Ex-Collegians | 7-0 | W | | Toronto, OH | Kilgus Field | | |
| Sun | 11/30/1924 | H | Steubenville Ex-Collegians | 6-6 | T | | Toronto, OH | Kilgus Field | 1200 | |
| Sun | 12/7/1924 | A | Steubenville Ex-Collegians | 20-0 | W | | Steubenville, OH | | | |
