1921 APFA Awards |
| All-APFA | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Position | Team | Selectors |
| Scotty Bierce | E | Akron Pros | BC |
| Bob Nash | E | Buffalo All-Americans | BC BEN |
| Luke Urban | E | Buffalo All-Americans | BEN |
| Pete Henry | T | Canton Bulldogs | BC BEN |
| Bulger Lowe | T | Cleveland Tigers | BEN |
| Belf West | T | Canton Bulldogs | BC BEN |
| Al Nesser | G | Akron Pros | BC BEN |
| Swede Youngstrom | G | Buffalo All-Americans-Canton Bulldogs | BC |
| Doc Alexander | C | Rochester Jeffersons | BC BEN |
| Benny Boynton | QB | Washington Senators-Rochester Jeffersons | BC BEN |
| Elmer Oliphant | HB | Buffalo All-Americans | BC BEN |
| Pete Stinchcomb | HB | Decatur Staleys | BEN |
| Andy King | FB | Akron Pros | BEN |
| Dick King | FB | Hammond Pros | BC |
| BC=Buffalo Courier BEN=Buffalo Evening News |